Was Abraham asked to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?

14:25

76 views · Last viewed: 1 day ago
Uploaded: 18 May 2026 (3 months ago) · Shared: 23 Jun 2026

Video Description (from Youtube)

Dr. Shabir Ally and Dr. Safiyyah Ally explore one of the most debated questions in the story of Abraham’s sacrifice: was the son Isaac or Ishmael? While many Muslims assume the Quran clearly

identifies the son as Ishmael, Dr. Shabir explains that the Quran does not name him directly. Instead, scholars have drawn conclusions by comparing Quranic narratives, biblical accounts, and the logic of the story itself. They examine why some early Muslim commentators identified the son as Isaac, why the majority Muslim view later shifted toward Ishmael, and why the Quran may have left the question open while focusing on the deeper message of faith, sacrifice, obedience to God, and trust in divine wisdom.

If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by:
Visiting our website http://www.QuranSpeaks.com OR
Sending an etransfer to iGive@QuranSpeaks.com OR
Subscribing monthly at Patreon.com/QuranSpeaks

► DONATE: http://www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=quranspeaks

Facebook: http://www.Facebook.com/LetTheQuranSpeak
Instagram: http://www.Instagram.com/QuranSpeaks.tv
Twitter: http://www.Twitter.com/Quran_Speaks

DISCLAIMER
All videos are shared for educational and information purposes only. All videos are hosted and viewable on Youtube servers. Video titles are generated using the original video title; overall content theme including actual dialogue and speech (Transcript); and A.I-based recommendations with a focus on SEO, keyword density, and internal search functions. The video title does not represent the views held by the Youtube video uploader, or any individual, organisation or business.

If you spot any mistake, omission or give feedback, kindly Contact Us with details

Watch on Youtube Upload Video Report Video

Search Results on 'Was Abraham asked to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael? | Shabir Ally'

Topics include Shabir Ally (1)

Who is Shabir Ally? Shabir Ally is a Canadian Muslim preacher who serves as the president of the Islamic Information & Dawah Centre International in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Ally is known for promoting a contextual interpretation of the Quranic verses, but seeks to find their justification in similar expressions within the Christian Bible. He has debated William Lane Craig, David Wood, Nabeel Qureshi, Michael Licona and John Dominic Crossan. He has also debated apologists James White and Jay Smith.

Youtube Videos on Shabir Ally (131)

What is God like: Tawhid or Trinity? - Shabir Ally vs Nabeel Qureshi 2:55:44 990 views
Is Jesus God? - Shabir Ally vs James White 2:17:11 760 views
Homosexuality - An Islamic Perspective - Shabir Ally 13:52 939 views
Early Life of Moses - Shabir Ally 7:12 509 views
Lessons from the Life of Prophet Moses - Shabir Ally 11:58 773 views
Easter & Jesus - Shabir Ally 10:43 680 views
Noah the Movie: An Islamic Perspective - Shabir Ally 10:39 618 views
Did the earliest disciples view Jesus as God? - James White vs Shabir Ally 2:17:27 491 views
Morality and Religion - Sikhism, Islam, Atheism - Shabir Ally, Mike Lake, Jagraj Singh 42:45 701 views
Was Apostle Paul founder of Christianity? - Shabir Ally vs George Shillington 2:18:16 1406 views
Jesus' Prophesy of the Paraclete & Other Issues - Shabir Ally 56:33 320 views
The Historicity of the Life of Jesus in the Gospels - Shabir Ally vs John Dominic Crossan 2:56:24 895 views
Does God Really Exist? An answer to ATHEISM in a Godless Society - Shabir Ally 1:53:41 531 views
The nature of Scripture - Shabir Ally vs Luis Dizon 2:12:07 465 views
Who is God in the World Religions? - Shabir Ally 1:46:39 455 views
Was the Resurrection a Hoax? - Shabir Ally vs William Lane Craig 2:19:02 471 views
Baby Jesus: His Birth in the Bible & the Quran - Shabir Ally vs Dean Canonico 2:17:40 727 views
Jesus, Son of God or Prophet of Islam? - Shabir Ally vs David Wood 4:19:50 959 views
Did Muhammad give us the truth about Jesus? - Shabir Ally vs David Wood 1:50:26 840 views
Were There Multiple Versions of the Quran? - Shabir Ally 3:29 1012 views
Bridging World Religions: Exploring Judaism - Shabir Ally 9:11 454 views
Patterns of Numerical Values in the Quran - Shabir Ally 10:50 719 views
Is There Any Proof of Noah's Ark? - Shabir Ally 2:26 445 views
Is the Bible a Book of Peace? - Shabir Ally vs David Wood 2:13 697 views
In the Quran, why does God call Mary, the Sister of Aaron? - Shabir Ally 4:48 626 views
Why does Islam encourage Circumcision? - Shabir Ally 1:20 492 views
Is the Quran REALLY The Word Of God? - Shabir Ally 10:51 760 views
Will Hellfire ever be empty one day? - Shabir Ally 2:25 523 views
Is the punishment of Stoning from the Islamic Shariah? - Shabir Ally 5:55 631 views
Which is the book of Peace: Bible or Quran? - Jay Smith vs Shabir Ally 1:58:23 759 views
Did Pontius Pilate release Jesus? - Shabir Ally 3:35 622 views
Did Adam & Eve's Children Commit Incest? - Shabir Ally 4:08 745 views
How are we Saved? - Samuel Green vs Shabir Ally 2:05:34 553 views
Did Jesus rise from the dead? - Mike Licona vs Shabir Ally 2:35:56 531 views
Biblical Christianity or Islam? - Dave Hunt vs Shabir Ally 2:39:06 1176 views
What does Islam say about Hinduism and Buddhism? - Shabir Ally 5:50 616 views
Is the Gospel of Barnabas real? - Shabir Ally 2:45 545 views
Jesus' Birth in the Quran and Bible - Shabir Ally 11:08 591 views
Did Jesus claim to be God? - James White vs Shabir Ally 2:18:38 673 views
Who did Abraham sacrifice, Ishmael or Isaac? - Shabir Ally 3:58 554 views
Which is God's word, Quran or Bible? - Sam Shamoun vs Shabir Ally 2:26:24 1036 views
Do Jews believe Ezra is the Son of God? - Shabir Ally 2:02 511 views
Do Muslims believe Jesus will Return? - Shabir Ally 3:51 449 views
Did Jesus die on the Cross and rise from the dead? - David Seccombe vs Shabir Ally 2:54:58 396 views
Who exactly is God? - Shabir Ally vs Richard Lucas 1/2 1:16:37 371 views
Who exactly is God? - Shabir Ally vs Richard Lucas 2/2 1:44:59 380 views
Are the the views of Jesus in the Bible correct? - Shabir Ally vs James White 2:09:53 779 views
Bible or Quran: Which is the word of God? - Jay Smith vs Shabir Ally 2:34:56 1227 views
Did Jesus rise from the Dead? - Shabir Ally vs Mike Licona 2:36 763 views
The Quran on the Crucifixion? - Shabir Ally 6:50 1051 views
The Torah and Gospel (Injeel) in the Quran - Shabir Ally 3:02 1204 views
In Quran 2:62, will Jews and Christians go to Heaven? - Shabir Ally 3:05 1347 views
The Quran on the Christian Trinity - Shabir Ally 8:53 1442 views
Discovery of the Oldest Quran Fragments - Shabir Ally 8:38 589 views
Will Non-Muslims be 'Losers' in the Next Life? - Shabir Ally 2:58 304 views
Are Jews and Christians the 'People of the Book'? - Shabir Ally 7:00 599 views
Exploring Buddhism - Shabir Ally 9:27 517 views
Abraham's Sacrifice - Shabir Ally 9:42 509 views
Is Evolution Compatible With Islam? - Shabir Ally 3:48 682 views
Who Created God? - Shabir Ally 1:08 343 views
Was Muhammad Uncertain of His Own Salvation? - Shabir Ally 4:23 600 views
I am Gay. Why Is God testing me with Homosexuality? - Shabir Ally 3:59 926 views
Ezekiel and Jethro in the Quran - Shabir Ally 8:46 846 views
Did God take 6 days to create the World? - Shabir Ally 2:29 657 views
Did Apostle Paul Invent Christianity? - Shabir Ally vs Cliff Forward 1:58:13 1277 views
How are we Saved? - Shabir Ally vs Samuel Green 2:05:34 478 views
The Theory of Evolution - Shabir Ally 9:05 500 views
Jesus: Man, Myth or God? - Shabir Ally vs Andy Bannister 1:45:23 530 views
Trinity does not make logical sense - Shabir Ally 24:02 633 views
Evolution Theory evidence in Quran - Shabir Ally 12:36 638 views
Why Quran refers to Injeel as a book? - Shabir Ally 2:54 838 views
Resisting Pornography - Shabir Ally 10:40 408 views
Which is more violent, the Quran or Bible? - Shabir Ally vs Douglas Jacoby 1:58:28 663 views
In Quran 18:86, the Sun sets in the murky Sea - Shabir Ally 3:52 924 views
How the Quran was preserved for 1400 years? - Shabir Ally 12:10 546 views
#boycottHajj or not? - Shabir Ally 9:58 452 views
Historical Origins of Trinity - Shabir Ally 2:43 805 views
Blasphemy Laws in Islam - Shabir Ally 11:20 421 views
Does God Exist? - Shabir Ally 6:29 342 views
Is Muhammad a true Prophet of God? - Shabir Ally 12:31 710 views
Why Does God Allow Suffering? - Shabir Ally 13:11 395 views
Is the Quran really from God? - Shabir Ally 14:13 797 views
How Quran was preserved for 1400 years? - Shabir Ally 15:39 633 views
Mathematical Miracles in the Quran - Shabir Ally 12:54 957 views
Jesus might not come back - Shabir Ally 2:37 521 views
On Quran 4:95, did Muhammad change this verse? - Shabir Ally 1:40 747 views
In Quran 43:61, how does Islam portray Jesus? - Shabir Ally 2:39 862 views
Belief in One God is what sets Islam apart from other religions - Shabir Ally 3:40 410 views
How can I tell my dead parents how much I love & miss them? - Shabir Ally 2:46 303 views
The Meaning & Purpose of Life - Shabir Ally 10:09 344 views
Noah in the Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 12:15 1066 views
Proof of Muhammad as the Final Prophet - Shabir Ally 2:51 592 views
Adam in the Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 15:21 641 views
Is Allah the Moon God? - Shabir Ally 4:47 647 views
Do Muslims Worship Muhammad? - Shabir Ally 2:43 387 views
Prophets in the Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 11:54 980 views
Buddha a Prophet? - Shabir Ally 2:26 868 views
Lot in the Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 6:16 695 views
Jacob in the Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 8:46 630 views
Job in the Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 9:38 502 views
Moses in the Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 12:26 644 views
Aaron in the Bible and Quran - Shabir Ally 8:34 892 views
David in the Bible and Quran - Shabir Ally 13:19 650 views
Importance of Virgin Mary in Islam - Shabir Ally 2:31 371 views
Did Muhammad Exist? - Shabir Ally 13:44 302 views
Aisha was not a Child upon marriage to Muhammad - Abu Layth & Shabir Ally 9:17 504 views
Abraham's Wife, Hagar in Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 8:23 683 views
God is in Control of COVID - Shabir Ally 10:52 626 views
COVID Vaccine is a Global Effort to keep People Safe - Shabir Ally 11:15 595 views
Does Quran include 10 Commandments? - Shabir Ally 7:16 1344 views
Moses' Mother in Bible & Quran - Shabir Ally 7:33 758 views
Book Review: The Evidence For Jesus by James Dunn - Shabir Ally 11:09 782 views
Jesus submitted to God - Shabir Ally 3:22 441 views
Did God send Female Prophets? \| Shabir Ally 12:43 613 views
Why Muslims Do Not Drink Alcohol or Eat Pork? \| Shabir Ally 14:34 802 views
In Quran 17:1, Muhammad's Night Journey (Isra-Miraj) was Physical or Spiritual? \| Shabir Ally 11:07 1103 views
Is Religion Compatible With Human Evolution and Adam? \| Shabir Ally 12:38 1405 views
Do Prophets Commit Sins? \| Shabir Ally 9:28 806 views
What Everyone Should Know About Islam \| Shabir Ally 6:13 392 views
How near is God to me? \| Shabir Ally 8:12 134 views
Belief in One God \| Shabir Ally 12:00 134 views
Whoever believes in God will be saved from Hellfire (Perennialism) \| Shabir Ally 8:38 189 views
Abraham, the Grandfather of Monotheism \| Shabir Ally 13:04 181 views
Jesus and His Call to Renewal \| Shabir Ally 15:02 100 views
Moses, the Model Prophet \| Shabir Ally 16:10 185 views
Why Prophets and Scriptures were revealed gradually over time \| Shabir Ally 15:11 177 views
Return of Jesus The Messiah \| Shabir Ally 18:09 183 views
In Quran 27:18, did Solomon speak to Ants or People? \| Shabir Ally 9:48 313 views
Did God deceive Christians on Jesus? \| Shabir Ally 4:52 157 views
The 'Hijab' was a curtain/physical partition within Muhammad's home \| Shabir Ally 17:02 110 views
Was Abraham asked to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael? \| Shabir Ally 14:25 76 views

Say, We believe in God and what was sent down to us, and what was sent down to Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Jacob and the Tribes, and what was given to Moses, Jesus and all the Prophets by their Lord
Quran 2:136

Jesus said to him, 'I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me
John 14:6

Ye have heard how I said unto you, I go away, and come again unto you. If ye loved me, ye would rejoice, because I said, I go unto the Father: for my Father is greater than I
John 14:28

Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God is one Lord
Deuteronomy 6:4

The Creator of the heavens and the earth. He has made for you mates from yourselves, and for the cattle (also) mates. By this means He creates you (in the wombs)
Quran 42:11

O people of the Scripture (Jews and Christians): Come to a word that is just between us and you, that we worship none but Allah, and that we associate no partners with Him, and that none of us shall take others as lords besides Allah
Quran 3:64

I can of mine own self do nothing: as I hear, I judge: and my judgment is just; because I seek not mine own will, but the will of the Father which hath sent me
John 5:30

Indeed, We have revealed to you, (O Muhammad), as We revealed to Noah and the prophets after him. And we revealed to Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Jacob, the Descendants, Jesus, Job, Jonah, Aaron, and Solomon, and to David We gave the book (of Psalms)
Quran 4:163

Blessed be He Who has placed in the heaven big stars, and has placed therein a great lamp (sun), and a moon giving light. And He it is Who has put the night and the day in succession
Quran 25:61

He (Jesus) Himself stood in their midst and said to them, Peace be to you
Luke 24:36

O My servants who have transgressed against themselves, do not despair of the mercy of God. Indeed, God forgives all sins. Indeed, it is He who is the Forgiving, the Merciful
Quran 39: 53

Indeed, man is in loss, except those who have faith and do righteous deeds, and advise one another to truth and patience
Quran 103:1-3

The first of all the commandments is, Hear, O Israel; The Lord our God is one Lord
Mark 12:29

Jesus saith unto her, Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father: but go to my brethren, and say unto them, I ascend unto my Father, and your Father; and to my God, and your God
John 20:17

And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? that is to say, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?
Matthew 27:46

Verily, verily, I say unto you, The servant is not greater than his lord; neither he that is sent greater than he that sent him.
John 13:16

Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind
Matthew 22:37

By myself I can do nothing; I judge only as I hear, and my judgment is just, for I seek not to please myself but him who sent me.
John 5:30

Then answered Jesus and said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, The Son can do nothing of himself, but what he seeth the Father do: for what things soever he doeth, these also doeth the Son likewise.
John 5:19

Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.
Matthew 7:21

Remember the former things, those of long ago; I am God, and there is no other; I am God, and there is none like me
Isaiah 49:9

Connect: Facebook | Twitter | Youtube

MuslimProphets.com is an educational website on the Prophets of God: David, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad, who established the Abrahamic faiths of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. MuslimProphets.com explores contemporary social themes through Scripture, Evidences, Photo, Video, Maps, Current Affairs, Debate and 'alternative' Views held by Theologians, Apologists, Scholars and Street Preachers. Take a Site Tour

In accordance with Islamic etiquette, all prophet names should be followed with 'Peace Be Upon Him (PBUH)'. This is omitted to minimise text.

DISCLAIMER: All website content is for general information and educational purposes only and available in the public domain. Whilst all information comes from sources believed to be reliable, this cannot be guaranteed. External links are provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only. They do not constitute endorsement or approval for any products, services or comments by organizations or individuals. Title and Text links may be edited for external SEO, internal site and keyword search purposes. We bear no responsibility for the accuracy, legality, or content found on any external website or its subsequent links. Unless indicated, all images and content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License distributed by Wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons, Pixabay, Pxhere, Pexels, Unsplash, Flickr and others. All Torah, Psalms, Old and New Testament Bible quotes are from the King James Version (KJV) Holy Bible in the public domain. All Quran quotes are from Taqi-ud-Din al-Hilali/Muhsin Khan English Quran translation.

ALWAYS DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH. If you spot any mistake, error or omission of information, contact us so we can correct it.

	Are you a Muslim? 3 mins \| Online Test
	10 Commandments - Bible vs Quran
	Ishmael and Isaac in Bible and Quran
	The Lost Gospels
	Trinity - 13 Three God Pagan concepts
	Women in Religion

	Torah 5 BOOKS
	Psalms 1 BOOK
	Old Testament 32 BOOKS
	New Testament 27 BOOKS
	Apocrypha 1885 14 BOOKS
	Gospels/Texts 367 BOOKS
	Codex 120 BOOKS
	Quran 1 BOOK
	Hadith 10 BOOKS

Was Abraham asked to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael? | Shabir Ally

Video Description (from Youtube)

Search Results on 'Was Abraham asked to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael? | Shabir Ally'

Topics include Shabir Ally (1)

Who is Shabir Ally?

Youtube Videos on Shabir Ally (131)

NEWS | 1,818

ARTICLES | 159

SCRIPTURE | 580

SUBSCRIBE