3:40
250 views
·
Last viewed: 17 hrs ago
Uploaded: 17 May 2024 (2 years ago) · Shared: 11 May 2026
Video Description (from Youtube)
🎙️ In this episode of the Real Talk Podcast, we’re thrilled to welcome back to the channel the eminent Mr. James Howard-Johnston to discuss the contents of his recent article, “The Qur’an as aHistorical Source” 📜✨ (link below ⬇️).
James Howard-Johnston is a Lecturer in Byzantine Studies at the University of Oxford, and author of the monumental Witnesses to a World Crisis: Historians and Histories of the Middle East in the Seventh Century — a masterclass in deep source analysis. His work examines the formative phase of Islam through both Islamic and non-Islamic sources, offering an unparalleled look at this pivotal historical period.
In this discussion, we explore:
🔍 Why he considers the Qur’an a key historical source
📆 What a chronological reading of the text—alongside other materials—can reveal about the Prophet’s evolving role as both a spiritual and political leader of a religion that reshaped the world
🔗 Link to the article:
https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/jiqsa-2024-0006/html
💬 Be sure to like, share, subscribe, and let us know your thoughts on this powerful and thought-provoking discussion!
DISCLAIMER
All videos are shared for educational and information purposes only. All videos are hosted and viewable on Youtube servers. Video titles are generated using the original video title; overall content theme including actual dialogue and speech (Transcript); and A.I-based recommendations with a focus on SEO, keyword density, and internal search functions. The video title does not represent the views held by the Youtube video uploader, or any individual, organisation or business.
If you spot any mistake, omission or give feedback, kindly Contact Us with details
EXPLORE TOPICS :
HAJJ |
25
SKEPSISLAMICA |
17
PRE-ISLAM |
27
ISLAM |
448
EARLY ISLAM |
16
MUSLIM |
305
JAMES HOWARD-JOHNSTON |
9
POLYTHEIST |
11
POLYTHEISM |
11
Search Results on 'Why did the post-Islam Hajj pilgrimage continue many polytheist, pre-Islam Hajj rituals? | James Howard-Johnston | Skepsislamica'
SCROLL TO: TOPICS | 11 NEWS | 97 ARTICLES | 6 FAQ | 16 VIDEO | 430 LINKS | 0Topics include Hajj, Skepsislamica, Islam, James Howard-Johnston (11)
Who are Nation of Islam?
The Nation of Islam, abbreviated as NOI, is an African American political and religious movement. Founded in Detroit, Michigan, United States, by Wallace D. Fard Muhammad on July 4, 1930. Its stated goals are to improve the spiritual, mental, social, and economic condition of African Americans in
the United States and all of humanity. |
What is Hajj?
The Hajj is an annual Islamic pilgrimage to Mecca, Saudi Arabia, the holiest city for Muslims. It is a mandatory religious duty for Muslims that must be carried out at least once in their lifetime by all adult Muslims who are physically and financially capable of undertaking the journey, and can
support their family during their absence. In Islamic terminology, Hajj is a pilgrimage made to Kaaba, the "House of God", in the sacred city of Mecca in Saudi Arabia. The rites of Hajj are performed over 5 or 6 days. It is a demonstration of the solidarity of the Muslim people, and their submission to God (Allah). |
Who is Yusuf Islam?
Yusuf Islam (born Steven Demetre Georgiou 1948), commonly known by his stage name Cat Stevens. He later became known as Yusuf and eventually Yusuf/Cat Stevens, is a British singer-songwriter and multi-instrumentalist. His musical style consists of folk, pop, rock, and, in his later career, Islamic
music. He was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2014. |
Who are Muslim Brotherhood?
The Muslim Brotherhood is a Sunni Islamist organization founded in 1928 by Hassan al-Banna, primarily in Egypt. It's a transnational group with a significant presence in many Muslim countries, aiming to establish a state governed by Islamic law, known as Sharia. The Brotherhood's stated goals
include spreading Islamic morals, combating what it deems "ignorant societies," and promoting a "new man" rooted in Islamic values. |
Who are Skepsislamica?
We spotlight perspectives in Islamic history that often go unnoticed, keeping you informed on the latest academic research and discussions. Our content is non-sectarian and grounded in rigorous academic approaches to Islamic studies, offering deep and thoughtful analysis.
|
What is Pre-Islam?
Pre-Islam refers to the period in history before the emergence and widespread adoption of Islam. It specifically denotes the time before the Prophet Muhammad's revelations and the establishment of Islamic faith, culture, and civilization.
|
What is Islam?
Early Islam or the history of Islam is believed, by most historians to have originated with Muhammad's mission in Mecca and Medina at the start of the 7th century CE. Although Muslims regard this time as a return to the original faith passed down by the Abrahamic prophets, such as Adam, Noah
Abraham, Moses, David, Solomon, and Jesus, with the submission (Islam) to the will of God. According to the traditional account, the Islamic prophet Muhammad began receiving what Muslims consider to be divine revelations in 610 CE, calling for submission to the one God, preparation for the imminent Last Judgement, and charity for the poor and needy. |
Who are Thinking Muslim?
The Thinking Muslim Podcast explores key issues in depth with esteemed Muslim thinkers, academics and scholars??.
|
Who is James Howard-Johnston?
James Howard-Johnston (born 1942) is an English historian of the Byzantine Empire. He was University Lecturer in Byzantine studies at the University of Oxford. He is an emeritus fellow of Corpus Christi College, Oxford. His approach to Byzantium follows that of Edward Gibbon and concentrates on
comparisons between the Byzantine state and its Western counterparts. Howard-Johnston has also done research on Late Antiquity, especially the Roman-Persian Wars and the early history of Islam. |
Who is Muslim Lantern?
This is the official channel of Muhammed Ali. The Main Goals of The Muslim Lantern are Tackling Muslim Contemporary Issues, Refuting The Doubts put Forward Against Islam And Educating those who seek Guidance and Truth.
|
Who is Orthodox Muslim?
Orthodox Muslim considers himself a humble servant of Allah. A Muslim who has taken an interest in comparative religion & theology.
|
News on Hajj, Skepsislamica, Islam, James Howard-Johnston (97)
Articles on Hajj, Skepsislamica, Islam, James Howard-Johnston (6)
1.Are you a Muslim?
|
2.Islam and Hinduism
|
3.Jesus the Muslim
|
4.10 Commandments - Christian vs Muslim
|
5.Islam: Biggest Threat to Europe?
|
| 6.Hajj - How Islam purified the Pagan 'Kabah' Ritual in 22 Steps
|
FAQ on Hajj, Skepsislamica, Islam, James Howard-Johnston (16)
Youtube Videos on Hajj, Skepsislamica, Islam, James Howard-Johnston (430)
ISIS, 
Jesus sent by God with a Message from God, 
Abraham invites his father to 
Many Christians Converted To 
The 
Great British 
Ishmael in 
Women In 
My Journey to 
How the Bible Led Me to 
Jesus: A Prophet of 
Jesus told me to convert to 
Former Christian Preacher Speaks About 
My Journey To 
Morality and Religion - Sikhism, 
Convert from Hinduism to 
Similarities between 
What does 
Was Jesus a 
Jesus of the Holy Bible vs Jesus of the Quran (
Is Christianity and 
What's common between 
New 
Why am I a 
3 Jamaican Christians explain why they chose 
From Youth Christian Minister to 
From Youth Christian Minister to 
From Youth Christian Minister to 
What is 
Jesus, Son of God or Prophet of 
Jesus in 
Why Christian Minister US Marine Embraced 
His father's books turned him to 
Who do you follow: Apostle Paul or Jesus and the Disciples? - Christian vs 
Jewish Rabbi Admits 
My Journey To 
From Christianity to 
Epic 
Why does 
Zoroastrianism influenced Judaism, Christianity and 
How contradictions in the Christian Bible led me to 
Biblical Christianity or 
What does 
Science and 
Jesus in 
Salvation in Christianity and 
Jesus in 
Jesus: Jew, Christian or 
Jesus in 
Theory of Evolution in 
Womens rights in 
Life of a Jewish Rabbi in Indonesia, the largest 
Dead Sea Scrolls are closer to 
Does White Supremacy exist in 
Science and 
Jewish historian on 
Jewish historian speech on 
Jewish historian admits all prophets were 
David, Australian science teacher converts to 
David, Australian science teacher converts to 
Prophet Jesus in 
A Jewish Rabbi presents 
Was Adam an African? - SaRa vs Jamaican 
Who decides who is a 
Similarities Between Christianity And 
Pre-Islamic Allah - Gary & Godwin vs 
From Judaism to 
From Judaism to 
From Judaism to 
From Judaism to 
Education was invented by 
Education was invented by 
Is 
The Crusades: The 
Is 
Salvation in 
Salvation in 
Christian-
Christian-
Does 
No Compulsion in Religion. Yet 
Srebrenica 1995 - What happened to the 8,000 
Origins of 
Why 
Ricardo, a Catholic Christian convert shares his journey to 
What does 
No Racism in 
In Psalm 137:9, it is injustice to kill the Baby and innocent Donkey - 
The origins of 
Slavery in 
Slavery in 
Racism and 
A Christian Mormon converts to 
Are 
You are a Unitarian. You are a 
Is there a place for Homosexuality in 
Homosexuality in 
Homosexuality in 
The Scientific Method cannot provide an Evolutionary explanation for Intuition. It's Impossible! - Shabir Yusuf vs Ex-
The Scientific Method cannot provide an Evolutionary explanation for Intuition. It's Impossible! - Shabir Yusuf vs Ex-
The Scientific Method cannot provide an Evolutionary explanation for Intuition. It's Impossible! - Shabir Yusuf vs Ex-
ISIS has no foundation in 
Malcolm X: America Needs 
Randy, US Army Officer converts to 
Ikram from Scotland converts to 
In the 21st Century, the Bible has been corrupted. Portugese Michael converts to 
3 Jews and a 
When The 
Why I converted to 
How 
Christian Preacher converts to 
Former Baptist Minister Converts To 
Is Evolution Compatible With 
USA American Prisoners convert to 
In Deuteronomy 18:18, the prophet to come was Joshua (Judaism), Jesus (Christianity) or Muhammad (
All Terrorists Are 
Is 
In Science, happiness is a myth. In 
In Science, happiness is a myth. In 
Jesus prayed the Jewish Prayer (Amida), like a 
Jesus the Jew was a Unitarian. Monotheism is common amongst Unitarian Christians and 
Abraham, Hagar and 
Noureddine, an American military veteran converts to 
Sexual Slaves, Prostitution and 
Muhammad was Semi-Vegetarian. It's OK to be 
Moses was a 
Introduction to 
Arthur Wagner, former AfD German Nationalist converts to 
Can Salvation be found outside of 
Nabateans: Builders of Petra (pre-
Conversations with 
20% of Kuwaitis suffer from Diabetes. I blame 
Greater Israel & Planned Destruction of Arab 
Where's the evidence British 
Are 
Tommy Robinson is no Power Ranger. Grooming Gangs are not 
Jesus in 
Jewish Rabbis admit 
Theological Similarities between Christianity & 
Introduction to 
Similarities between 
I am not a Slave. I am an Atheist, Christian and 
Islamophobia USA: 
Myanmar's Anti-
Christian Zionism: American Evangelical Christians pursue War with 
God created me short-sighted so I wear glasses. I converted to Athiesm - Mohammed Hijab vs Ex-
David vs Goliath story in 
According to 
God commanded Muhammad to fight until the people converted to 
We are poisoned Slaves in a controlled System. 
History of 
Empire of 
Empire of 
Empire of 
I want to convert to 
Pornography in 
Child 'Grooming Gangs' have nothing to do with 
Jesus never ate Pig. He despised the Swine and Pig. Follow Jesus and accept 
John 1:1 proves Jesus' divinity, and John 1:14 shows Jesus' humanity - 
Practical Advice for New 
Jews bring people to God. I am happy Sinead O Connor converted to 
Before Slavery, the Black Man was a 
Nation of 
Life of Prophet Muhammad - Yusuf 
Why Inmates Are Converting to 
The Oneness of God ('Monotheism') is the most powerful message - Yusuf 
Jesus' toenail is not holy. Your thick head talks crap - 
My journey why I converted to 
Latinos Converting to 
Blasphemy Laws in 
My Journey from Atheism, Big Bang, Science to 
In Quran 65:4, Ibn Kathir and Ibn Abbas allow for Child Marriage in 
Introduction to 
Homosexuality in 
The Message: Story of 
Teaching Homosexuality/LGBTQ to 
Pornography has enslaved 
Pre-
Maimonides (1204 AD), a Jewish scholar is proof 
Maimonides (1204 AD), a Jewish scholar is proof 
Why US Prisoners convert to 
How does Judaism view Christianity & 
In 
The Future of 
Should Americans fear 
In Matthew 15:24, Jesus called the Woman a Dog, then medicated her Daughter - Kane vs 
1000 
The Black Stone and Safa-Marwa 'most likely' originate from pre-
History of 
My Convert Story to 
In Quran 43:61, how does 
What is the 
Historians write of many Kabah's or Pilgrimage sites in pre-
In 
Any White Man who accepts 
Belief in One God is what sets 
After 9/11, I read of 'Muhammad & the 40 Thieves' and rejected 
Concept of a 'Unified' God in 
Quit Hating! Understand 
Every Christian must learn about Jesus in 
Who is Muhammad, Messenger of God, Prophet of 
Girls go into 
Jesus: A Central Figure In 
Jesus in 
In Chicago and elsewhere, Latinos convert to 
The Nation of 
Abortion in 
The Quran: Primary Source of 
The Jesus of 
Apple/Google Smartphone 'Coronavirus contact tracing' may increase policing of Immigrant & 
Former 40-Year Christian Minister converts to 
Pornography in 
Importance of Virgin Mary in 
As a 
Jesus In 
English Man realizes he is a 
Did Michael Jackson die a 
Converting from Jehovah Witness to 
The 6 Point Plan to 'normalize' LGBT/Homosexuality in the 
All 
Historically, Slavery in 
In Christianity, God shares love with Jesus. In 
Cat Stevens, Fame & The 'Islamic' Spiritual Life - Russell Brand & Yusuf 
After Judaism, Christianity, 
In 
In 2012, UAE financially crackdown on 'terrorist' 
Was Buddha a 
I Converted to 
Transgender rights in 
Astrology in 
Is 
Homosexuality in 
Why Is Swine Pork Forbidden in Judaism, Christianity and 
Fasting in Buddhism, Christianity, 
Every 
The Kabahs, Gods and Stone Idol Worship in Pre-
How Quraysh Arabs influenced Muhammad to accept 
Freedom, Justice and Dignity missing in 
Weak 
Allah and The Gods of Pre-
Ancient Gods and Paganism in Pre-
Origins of Kabah in Pre-
Exploring Jesus The 
Persian Iranians Educated the Arab 
Jordan bans 
When Arab Leaders and Your 
Persian Origins of Orthodox Sunni 
Exploring the Origins of 
Numerology Is More Important Than 
Critical Insight into Origins of 
Saudi Arabia - Unity with Wahhabis and British Empire | 
POLL: 47% Israeli Jews support IDF Army killing all Palestinian Muslims in Gaza | 
Madkhali-Wahhabi Politics - Attack Palestine. Protect Saudi Arabia | 
UAE Exposed - Dirty Authoritarian Politics and Promotion of Sufi Values | Andreas Krieg | Thinking 
Saudi Arabia Wahhabi and British went to War Against Turkish Ottomans | 
'Bismillah' prayer existed in a multi-faith. pre-
Niqab (Face Covering) is NOT from 
Muhammad & The Empires of Faith: The Making of The Prophet of 
How 
Wahhabi/Salafis seek Peace With Zionist Israel. War with Deviant Muslims | 
Evidence of Gods in Pre-
Gods & Idols Worshipped in Pre-
Babies are born with Homosexual genes? | 
Origins of 
Judaism, Christianity & 
Angel Gabriel in 
Muhammad's Hadith in Sahih Bukhari written after 200 years | Joel Hayward | 
Did Arabs copy into 
Gaza Action 2025 - Where are the 
Abbasid Caliphate 747 AD: 
Rise of Abbasid Caliphate 747 AD: 
What Everyone Should Know About 
Will Israel control the 
Believer (Mumin) vs Submitter (
Was Jesus A 
Greater Israel needs More Land, More Settlements & More Blood? | HEATED Debate | 
WD Farad Muhammad - The Man, Myth, and Mystery of the Nation of 
Saddam and Gaddafi warned Arab 
Will A.I ChatGPT overtake 
Billionaires fixate over 
Moon God Theory in 
Chronology of 
The Truth about Shariah Law and UK Muslims | Liam Tuffs vs 
What 
Relationship between 
USA bombs 7 
In the History of Persian Iran lay the foundations of Sunni 
Sasanian and Roman Empires influenced Islamist Expansion | Khodadad Rezakhani | 
Perennialism (Universal Truth) exists in 
Arab Leaders fear Alternative Thoughts, Opinions and Ideas | Abdullah Alaoudh | Thinking 
Israel uses their 
The Evil of Madkhali 
The Golden Age of 
Influence of Persia and Zoroastrianism on 
Who is closer to Judaism: Christianity or 
The Search for Beauty in 
History of The Nation of 
Evolution of 
The Necessity of Suffering in 
Shameful Zionist Arab Leaders and 
Archaeology for the worship of Shams, a Sun God in Pre-
One Truth or Many? 
Ready to Convert to 
'Dirty Global Politics' is why UAE Supports Zionism over 
Where are the Muslims to stand against Israel? | 
The Mysterious, Hidden Origins of 
Israel's Objective to destroy Gaza and evict Palestinians | Norman Finkelstein | Thinking 
UAE heads 'War On Terror' Against Muslims | Farah El-Sharif | Thinking 
Animated History of 
Origins of The Nation of 
Quran affirms the Bible and Torah | DEBATE - 
The Hidden Costs of 
Evolution of The Allah God from Pre-
History of the 
History of the 
Development of The Quran's linguistics in Pre-
The Heart of 
Growth of 
Forget 
Zakariya & His Family in Light of 
Canada is closer to an Islamic State, than 
DEBATE - What is Better for Society, 
Fall of the Arab 
Muhammad's Night Journey and 
Is A.I dangerous for 
Pre-
Genocides Everywhere! Where are the 
Muslims say 'We Hear, We Obey our COVID Vaccine Master' | 
Quran written in multiple Arabic dialects, not just Hijazi | Marijn Van Putten | 
British Muslims and the Rise of Salafism | Umar Lee | 
Obey The 
Growing Influence of 
Jerusalem, City of 
Jerusalem, City of 
Rome-Persia War (602-628 AD) set the context for 
Fall of Arab Salafism and Rise of Greater Israel in 2025 | 
The Idols & Gods of Pre-
Muhammad's lineage to Ishmael is not from Pre-
Where did 
Christian Church points to 'ambiguous' Bible verses to claim Jesus is GOD | 
Did 
Saudi Arabia's 
Growth of 
Is 
Replace the 'ABRAHAMIC MATRIX' with 'Science & Art' from Aryan, European Whites | Richard Spencer vs Orthodox 
Where did Jesus claim to be GOD in The Bible? | 
Was Abraham a Torah-Observant Jew? | Aaron Golfiz vs Orthodox 
Why is Jesus a Prophet in 
Jews in Pre-
History of 
How America Got Owned - Zionist War Agenda and 9/11 War Against 
9/11 LIES and Zionist War Against 
Criticisms of 
NWO Satanism to replace Judaism, Christianity and 
Influence of Christan Sects over 
Palestinian suffering in Gaza turned me into a 
Who is Jesus The Messiah in 
Cycling Into Medina, 
History of 
In Christianity, Adam & Eve Sinned, so Jesus could Save - Judaism and 
Who was Allah in Pre-
'Tech Zionist' Settlers Expand into
EXPLORE TOPICS :
HAJJ |
25
SKEPSISLAMICA |
17
PRE-ISLAM |
27
ISLAM |
448
EARLY ISLAM |
16
MUSLIM |
305
JAMES HOWARD-JOHNSTON |
9
POLYTHEIST |
11
POLYTHEISM |
11
