Conflicting Views on Early Islamic History | Usuli Institute

Given all the unresolved historical debates resulting from conflicting reports in early Islamic history, how can we discern between mythology and what is reliable? What role does mythology play in providing historical context? In this episode, Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl discusses how to approach the Sirah and early Islamic history in a methodical manner that upholds historical scrutiny.

To catch up on Project Illumine visit this playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnuA5MsYIH_i9j4wHugwSyaWa6i1TVNaH

0:00 – Intro.
0:35 – Sources for the Sirah.
4:40 – Politically motivated reports.
8:15 – Child marriages in history.
12:00 – Substantive vs. formalistic approach to hadith.
14:00 – God left no doubt about what we need to know despite unresolved historical debates.
15:50 – The Prophet’s lineage.
26:30 – Mythology of Abrahamic lineage of Mecca.
30:15 – Jewish tribes patronized Arabs for their paganism.
31:54 – Jewish mythology surrounding an awaited Messiah.
38:00 – Khadija’s suspicion that Muhammad might be the awaited Prophet.

To catch up on Project Illumine visit this playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnuA5MsYIH_i9j4wHugwSyaWa6i1TVNaH

Instagram ~ @usuliinstitute
Twitter ~ @usuliinstitute
Facebook ~ https://www.facebook.com/usuliinstitute/

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR WEEKLY NEWSLETTER (scroll to the bottom)
https://www.usuli.org/

📚 Usuli Press - Check out our publications on the current state of the Muslim world
The Prophet's Pulpit Trilogy ~ https://amzn.to/40PBtnt
The Palestine Sermons ~ https://amzn.to/3AOxXiu

~ Spotify & Supercast ~
https://usuli.supercast.com!

🎥 Full list of our recorded khutbahs and their transcripts ~ https://bit.ly/usulikhutbahs

📰 The full list of articles referenced in this Khutbah can be found at http://www.usulinews.org/